There are 3 triplet brothers. They look identical. The oldest is John, he always tells the truth. The second is Jack, he always tells a lie. The third is Joe, he either tells the truth or a lie.

Jimmie went to visit them one day. He was wondering who was who. So he asked each person a question.

He asked the one who was sitting on the left: "Who is the guy sitting in the middle?". The answer was "He is John."
He asked the one who was sitting in the middle: "What is your name?". The answer was "I am Joe."
He asked the one who was sitting on the right: "What is the guy sitting in the middle?". The answer was "He is Jack."

Jimmie Dean got really confused. Basically, he asked 3 same questions, but he got 3 different answers. Would you find out who is who for Jimmie?

thori muskil hai

Mushkil tu hai per namumkin nhi hai

Mushkil hai kafi

iss ka jawab tou mujhe nahi aata laikin mujhe lagta ha k middle man john tha q k the first person jo introduce huwa wo john tha or wo jhoot nahi bolta i think so agay pata nahi

swal yeh tha k

Would you find out who is who for Jimmie?


sirf jhn ya kise eik ki baat nhi hoo rhi hai

left man is joe ,because if he was john he never tell that middle man is john,middle man is Jack and the third one who says "he is jack" is John because he never say lie.

i think i am right?

I Think you are Right
according to Riddle lets suppose
John= True
Jack= Liar
Joe= Wise


Question 1:
He asked the one who was sitting on the left: "Who is the guy sitting in the middle?". The answer was "He is John."

OR "He is True” OR "True is in Middle”

First sentence hints that left one is not True because
1- according to him "True is in Middle”.
2- if he is True, he will not say "True is in Middle”

So he may be Liar or Wise. In case of being Wise, he can speak Truth.
If this time he spoke truth and True is in Middle then

/ -------- /
Liar or Wise----True----Liar or Wise

Otherwise if this time he spoke Lie and True is not in the Middle
/ ---- / ----
Liar or Wise----Liar or Wise----True

Question 2:
He asked the one who was sitting in the middle: "What is your name?". The answer was "I am Joe."

“I am Wise” OR " Wise is in Middle”

He denied to be True so it is confirmed that in Question 1, the first one spoke a Lie and True is not in the Middle, So

/ ---- / ----
Liar or Wise----Liar or Wise----True

Now True is on right. Whatever he say, will be right

He asked the one who was sitting on the right: "What is the guy sitting in the middle?". The answer was "He is Jack."

“He is Liar” OR “Liar is in Middle”

So Our Equation will be

--------
Wise----Liar----True


and we know that
John=
Jack=
Joe=

SAMJH NAHI AYA

aya hota to kab ka solve bhi ker chuka hota

Agr aap chahtay hain to is ko Aur Ziada Explain kiya ja sakta hay
Waisay jab tak Dying Breath is par OK ki stamp na laga dain, yea Riddle Un solved hi rahay gi

Theek
hum bhi unki stamp ka wait ker rehay hain

infact iss ridle main unkown vaiable ziada hain,,, iss liye i think ke IT CAN'T BE EXPLAINED BY THE GIVEN DATA
it can only be told by dying breath,,,, and either his justification is acceptable or not,,, we will see later

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR APPRECIATION AND EXPLAINATION

Dyingbreadth bhai is ka answer bhi share karo..

Sir ji dyingbreath se q pooch rahe hain i am the winner kyoun ji............

Yes, you are 100% right.