Dear Mods,

I need to ask.. why do you close topic without giving any specific or valid reason before closing.
like below link topic

http://www.hulchul.net/HC/index.php?showto...932&st=1360

It happened because one of our fellow mod closed the topic without mentioning the reason..
Can Admins reply on this.. to make it clear why did this happened?

statement "Closed by me" is not a valid one to close any topic like that..
they should mention whats the reason behind.. if there is another topic like this. or 2 topics have been made..or some other reason..

please specify your reason of closing the topic.


Thanks

DarK AnGeL

Oh you are angry ..



ab kahan se shuru karoon main....
atually in FG speacial there are some members bringing back old topics
and more specifically `hamzaad`
we have requested, explained, warned on borad/ in PMs .. to him many many times
but still.. no use

U can say, we are now tired to repeat same things again and again
agar kisi aur memeber ne aisa kya hotta tu main aik baar phir se explain ker deti.. but

khair most of the membres, uptill now, know that activating any topic which was not replied for about 2 months or more is against HC policy
I and other Mods and Khalish bhai as well.. we have posted in many many posts this message


Bythe way ..we usually delete recent replies and this way send back the topic to archieves
but this time i left the post there.. for him to see and know that ..we will not appriciate replies on that topic
and later we may send it to archieves
as we dont like CLOSED POSTS on boared.. it doesnt give any good impression !!!

and the statement 8closed by me) was to acknowledge that Its Me taking this action

Aap topic dobarah visit kijiay aur post # 1365 daikh lijiay. Yeh post 6 mah pehle archieve meiN chali gaee thi aur Hamzad ne isse dobarah revive kiya hai, bawajood mere kaee dafa samjhaane per keh old post with heavy number of pages revive karne se system usse forum ke first page per barqaraar rakhne meiN slow ho jaata hai.

40 page ki iss post meiN aisi kya khaas baat thi jo isse 'posting here' keh kar start kar diya gaya? Yeh sirf 'maiN na manooN' waali baat hai.

I have no further comments on this issue.

well.. apki baat apni jagah darust hia.. ase kuch topics hote hian jinne dubara revive karna fazool hai.. but these are treasures of HC.. or yeh running topics hain.. ke is main post hosakti hia.. as you can see about the topic title n description.. due to new topics is pe inactivity hogai thi.. or yeh topic ka come back hua.. is main koi burai nai hia.. ap board ko le kar keh rahe ho slow horaha hai..to ase to bahut sare topics hian jo 40 pages kiya 100 karchuke hain... to kya ap sare topics maximum level pe pohanch kar close kardoge??? is this a right thing wid a topic????

Am sorry khalish bhai.. mera maqsad sirf yeh baat clear karna hia.. closing topic on this reason ke old topics hain.. to yeh baat sara sar ghalat hia..
for e.g mera apna topic FG main chal raha hia fruits n personalities ka.. 25-30 log us section ko regularly visit karte hain.. 2 month baad yeh archive hojayegi lekin jo naya member ayega woh purane pages reveal karega n us main reply kardega.. to kya ap us waqt bhi us topic ko close kardoge yeh keh kar ke yeh to jee purana hogaya hia.. main page pe raha to naye topics ke liye space nai hogi..
aik particular discussion based per baat apki jaiz bhi hia.. but ase running topic ke sath asa karna its not fair...

ap admins n mods hain.. ap behter hi chahtay hian.. but we members are also part of HC.. n we also want betterment n entertainment on the forum.. closing old topics is not acceptable

n rahi us post ki khas baat.. ap admin ho.. ap ki sirf 9000 posts hain.. ap ne logon ki shikayatien or maslihat ya shairi karke posts banai hian.. but we members are making it fun n entertainment.. we give time to it... we bring new things here on HC..n bringing old topics n making new topics is our right.. coz achay topic ki value ap log nai samjhenge.. but we members do.. hamari posts hian us main.. n aik topic close ho to we feel hurt.. jisne banaya woh bhi.. n jisne us main post ki time dia woh bhi..

agar ap hamari qadar karte ho.. to apko hamare topics ki bhi qadar karni hogi.. by closing topics is not the appropriate way..

I hope i made it clear.. n u have already said you have no further comments on this issue so i dont expect a reply.. but still you n other mods can read my feelings for HC n its treasures.. else its upto you guys.. you have the authority...


regards,
DarK AnGeL

Jo kuch aap ne likha maiN usski qadar karta hooN. Aap ki yeh baat bhi tasleem keh iss qism ke topics ko close nahi hona chahiye. Hamaare paas dosray zaraey bhi haiN un per bhi amal kiya jaa sakta hai.

MaiN archieves ko available rakhne ke haq meiN hooN aur yehi wajah thi keh HC update ke moqay per yeh option keh 'jin posts per 90 days tak activity na ho usse system automatically delete kar day' maiN ne bar.qaraar nahi rehne diya. Hamaare paas yeh option isse liye available hai keh hum system ko izzafi load se bachaane ki koshish karaiN. Jaisa aap ne kaha keh HC per loog bari mehnat aur mohabbat se posting karte haiN ... yehi ehsaas meraa bhi raha hai aur issi binaa per maiN ne yeh option active nahi hone diya.

Hamaari hama.waqt yehi koshish rehti hai keh hum HC usske members ke liye available rakhaiN aur voh ziyaadah se ziyaadah sahoolat se isse enjoy kar sakaiN.

Khush RahaiN