I want to start a discission about asool kafi shias most authentic book...What shia scholars say about it...

yeh woh book hai, jiss par shia hazraat kabhi bhi openly guftagoo karnaa pasand nahi kartay. main nay yeh book paRhee hai aur iss book par aik tafseeli review bhi publish howa hai jo shayad sipahay sahabaah waalouN nay chaapi hai.

meray aik bahoot hi qareebi shia dost say aik martabah issi book k hawalay say baat cheet howee to woh kahnay lagay k iss book maiN aisee koi baat nahi (jo maiN nay onhaiN ginwayee thee). maiN nay kahaa aap nay khud paRhee hai, kahnay laga nahi. maiN nay kahaa achchaa aap k pass hai yeh book. kahnay lagay nahi.... maiN nay kahaa aap yeh book lay aayaiN. hum dounouN mil kar issay study kartay haiN woh agree hogaye.... kaafi arsay k baad kahnay lagay maiN nay apnay mukhtalif shia marakaz / kutub khaanouN say check kia to pata chala k woh book ab nayaab hai. available nahi..... maiN nay kahaa aap ko woh book koi dega nahi, aur agar aap k pass hogi to aap meray pass layengay nahi.... kahnay lagaa yeh kia bewaqoofi wali baat kartya haiN aap.... maiN nay kahaa... chalo Theek hai, phir book maiN laataa houN, maiN nay paRhee bhi hai aur meray access maiN bhi hai yeh book... aap tayyar ho book saamnay rakh kar iss par discuss karnay ko... mausoof aaye byee shyee karnay lagay aur rahay faraar ikhteyaar kar gaye....

aap bhi inn chakkarouN maiN nah hi paraiN.... lakum deenakum waleyaa deen .... k qurani falsafay par amal karaiN.... jinn issues par 1400 saal maiN ittefaaq e roy nahi hosakaa woh aap HC ki chand posts say hul nahi karsaktay. bus apnay deen o imaan ki fikarkaraiN. Allah hum sab ko raahay raast par rahnay ki taufeeq day aameen.

Maslan aap ne uss mein se kya cheezain ginwai apnay dost ko ? kuch hamaray sath bhi share kijiye

aap nay to paRhee hi hogi brother. aap ko batlaanay ka kia faidah. aur jinhouN nay nahi paRhee, woh iss book k mundarjaat say door hi rahaiN to ach.chaa hai.

maiN shia-sunni ikhtelafaat par aik laa.haasil bahas ka aghaaz nahi karnaa chaah.ta dear.

Shia's most authentic book is quran, not the asool kafi.

agar aap hamari most authentic book par baat karna chahtay hain to quran par baat karain or agar asool kafi par baat karna cahhtay hain to isay shia's most authentic book na kahain. Thanx.

asool kafi bhi sahi bukhair, sahi muslim, sanan abu daud, tareekh ibn'ay kaseer etc. ki tarah ahadees par mubni 1 book hai jis main sahid, hasan or zaee'f har tarah ki rawayaat ikathi'thi ki gayi hain.... wats the big deal....

agar is ki koi rawaye't/hadees quran or sunnat k against jaati hai to shia people usay ya to reject karte hain ya zaeef qarar detay hain.

aik aur book hia iska muhe naam yaad nahin aarah aabhi mere aik dost ne bayata tha, uskee baree mein shia yeh kehtee hian ke yeh exist hi nahin kerte, kissi ko maloom hai main kis book ki baat ker rah hoon ? mere khayal mein uskee name mein Q atta hai kahin .......

iman e zamil,iman e kamil.
those are the names of the books i was talkn abt!

AOA...Thanks for all the comments uptill now,I want some more info about the book ,coz when u quote some thing from the book shia just deny the authenticity of the book...If somebody can give their scholars quotes about it....can any shia tell what is the criteria of the right or wrong ....and if a book has so many lies in it why dont they throw it ,or it least they should publish a suplement of asool kafi whom they should name LIES OF KAFI...and also give the reason why so many narrations became wrong after so many years.....OR IT IS JUST A TAQQIYA...I mean they believe on those narrations but as a taqqiya just denies them to conceal their Kufria believes like tehreef quran....But i have a good suggestion that if shia believes in quran they should send a LANAT on those who denied the Authenticity of quran more than any body else, coz it is the biggest sin

isi topic ki Post #6 ki pehli 2 lines....
c u

BEHAS BARAYE BEHAS SE PARHEZ KAREIN
MERI YEH TAJWEZ REAL PICTURE K LIYE HAI

THE BIGGEST BOMBSHELL TO SHIA WHO SLANDERS AISHA(RA)...ALI(RA)IS IMAM AND HIS SUNNA SHOULD BE FOLLOWED BY WHO CLAIM TO BE FOLLOWER TO HIM,IF HE CALLS HER UM-MUL-MOMININ WHAT RIGHT YOU HAVE TO SLANDER HER,IF U DO SO U R NOT MOMIM ACCORDING TO ALI(RA)


FOLLOWING IS THE QUOTATION OF UR FAMOUS BOOK NAHJUL BALAGHA WHICH CONTAINS ALI(RA) LETTERS AND QUOTES ETC...

IN WHICH ALI(RA) MENTION AISHA SO RESPECTFULLY.
"Driving UMMUL-MOMININ AISHA from her home at Madina and choosing Kufa and Basra as my residence."

NOW LISTEN TO THE VIDEO AND BE HONEST TO GOD IS HE A MOMIN WHO SLANDERS HER.

http://www.ahlelbayt.com/articles/ahlel-bayt/video-aisha